Support women-owned businesses
Kindle Unlimited
Unlimited reading. Over 4 million titles. Learn more
OR
$11.99 with 33 percent savings
Print List Price: $17.99

These promotions will be applied to this item:

Some promotions may be combined; others are not eligible to be combined with other offers. For details, please see the Terms & Conditions associated with these promotions.

Audiobook Price: $17.71

Save: $10.22 (58%)

You've subscribed to ! We will preorder your items within 24 hours of when they become available. When new books are released, we'll charge your default payment method for the lowest price available during the pre-order period.
Update your device or payment method, cancel individual pre-orders or your subscription at
Your Memberships & Subscriptions
Kindle app logo image

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.

Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.

Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.

QR code to download the Kindle App

Follow the author

Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.

The North Water: A Novel Kindle Edition

4.3 4.3 out of 5 stars 15,131 ratings

Now an AMC+ original miniseries event starring Colin Farrell and Jack O'Connell! A nineteenth-century whaling ship sets sail for the Arctic with a killer aboard in this dark, sharp, and highly original tale that grips like a thriller

One of The
New York Times Book Review's 10 Best Books of the Year, and named a Best Book of the Year by The Chicago Tribune, The Wall Street Journal, The Guardian, The New Statesman, Publishers Weekly, and The Chicago Public Library

Behold the man: stinking, drunk, and brutal. Henry Drax is a harpooner on the
Volunteer, a Yorkshire whaler bound for the rich hunting waters of the arctic circle. Also aboard for the first time is Patrick Sumner, an ex-army surgeon with a shattered reputation, no money, and no better option than to sail as the ship's medic on this violent, filthy, and ill-fated voyage.

In India, during the Siege of Delhi, Sumner thought he had experienced the depths to which man can stoop. He had hoped to find temporary respite on the
Volunteer, but rest proves impossible with Drax on board. The discovery of something evil in the hold rouses Sumner to action. And as the confrontation between the two men plays out amid the freezing darkness of an arctic winter, the fateful question arises: who will survive until spring?

With savage, unstoppable momentum and the blackest wit, Ian McGuire's
The North Water weaves a superlative story of humanity under the most extreme conditions.

National Bestseller

Longlisted for the Man Booker Prize

Winner of the RSL Encore Award

Finalist for the Los Angeles Book Prize

Popular Highlights in this book

Editorial Reviews

Review

The North Water is brilliant. A fast paced gripping story set in a world where ‘why’ is not a question and murder happens on a whim; but where a faint ray of grace and hope lights up the landscape of salt and blood and ice’ (Hilary Mantel on The North Water )

‘The strength of
The North Water lies in its well researched detail and persuasive descriptions of the cold, violence, cruelty and the raw, bloody business of whale killing. The Volunteer is rotten from the outset . . . The ship becomes a morally null universe, isolated on the north water. There are echoes here of Conrad’s Heart of Darkness’ (Helen Dunmore, The Guardian on The North Water )

‘McGuire delivers not only arresting depictions of bloody destruction, but moments of fine prose that recall Seamus Heaney's harsh music. For noirish thrills in an unusual setting, McGuire has the goods and the gore’ (Kirkus Reviews on The North Water )

‘A dark, brilliant yarn . . . An amazing journey’ (Publishing News on The North Water )

‘Ian McGuire’s second novel is an unflinching look at what men do, in extreme circumstances, for money, to survive, or for no reason at all. It has quite a lot in common with TV shows like HBO’s
Deadwood and its many descendants (including Peaky Blinders), and . . . it grips like a horror movie. The North Water is self consciously literary, thick with allusions to other books: Moby Dick, obviously; Conrad; Elizabeth Gaskell’s only historical novel, Sylvia’s Lovers; William Golding’s Rites of Passage trilogy; Frankenstein; Dracula; McGuire’s opening sentence is an ironic allusion to John’s gospel but it also recalls the beginning of the novel that The North Water most resembles, Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian’ (London Review of Books on The North Water )

'Blood, blubber and appalling human violence saturate a tale of a doomed 19th century whaling voyage to the Arctic' (The Sunday Times on The North Water )

'Set in the late 19th century, this is the tale of Patrick Sumner, a former army surgeon who joins a whaler bound for the waters of the Arctic Circle. Why would he take on such a dangerous task? He has a secret to hide. Also worth noting is that Ian McGuire's vivid novel is full of the smells of Victorian Hull, which include the "morning piss stink of just emptied night jars", "the usual tavern stench farts and pipe smoke and spilled ale", "the roaring stench of excrement and decay"; the "residual smell of horse dung and butchery"...I could go on' (The Times on The North Water )

'Prompted by Colm Toibin's superb review in
The New York Times, I lost my Kindle virginity to The North Water, Ian McGuire's chilling tale of whaling and depravity' (Madeline Kean, Sunday Independent (Ireland) on The North Water )

'This terse and grisly novel about the last days of the whaling industry is joint favourite to win the Man Booker Prize' (Sunday Telegraph on The North Water)

‘Should there be a dark horse on the [Man Booker] list, this is it. Forget slick, cool, funny and topical, this is the kind of book that captures the imagination, this is what fiction is about – the power of story.’ (Irish Times on The North Water)

'McGuire approached the telling of his novel with a linguistic panache seldom seen in contemporary British fiction' (The Irish Times on The North Water )

‘Powerful . . . A tale of startling brutality and violence. Undeniably gripping’ (Times Literary Supplement on The North Water)

'A stunning achievement, by turns great fun and shocking, thrilling and provocative. Behold: one of the finest books of the year' (James Kidd, Independent on The North Water )

'McGuire delivers one bravura set piece after another . . .
The North Water has, in places, a Conrad–Melville undercurrent, but for the most part it is Dickens’s influence that is most keenly felt . . . This is a stunning novel, one that snares the reader from the outset and keeps the tightest grip until its bitter end' (Financial Times on The North Water )

'Horrifically gripping. Such fine writing might have been lifted from the pages of Herman Melville’s
Moby Dick’ (Independent on Sunday on The North Water )

'Terrific, seamed with pitch black humour and possessed of a momentum that's kept up to the final, unexpected but resoundingly satisfying scene ... Inspired' (Stephanie Cross, Daily Mail on The North Water )

'As a storyteller, McGuire has a sure and unwavering touch, and he has engineered a superbly compelling suspense narrative . . . As a stylist, too, McGuire is never less than assured . . . a writer of exceptional craft and confidence' (Paraic O'Connell, Irish times on The North Water )

'Raw and compulsively readable . . . think
The Revenant for the Arctic Circle' (The Millions on The North Water )

'This book is quite a ride . . . The powerful story and the riches of the setting do not romanticise the past' (Erica Wagner, New Statesman on The North Water )

'
The North Water has exceptional power and energy' (Nick Rennison, Sunday Times on The North Water )

'A vivid read, full of twists, turns, period detail and strong characters . . . An enjoyable contrast to most literary fiction' (Robbie Millen, The Times on The North Water )

'Brilliant, fast paced, gripping. A tour de force of narrative tension and a masterful reconstruction of a lost world' (Hilary Mantel on The North Water )

  ‘Riveting and darkly brilliant . . .
The North Water feels like the result of an encounter between Joseph Conrad and Cormac McCarthy in some run down port as they offer each other a long, sour nod of recognition. McGuire has an extraordinary talent’ (Colm Toibin, New York Times on The North Water )

'A novel that takes us to the limits of flesh and blood. Utterly convincing and compelling, remorselessly vivid and insidiously witty. A startling achievement' (Martin Amis on The North Water )

‘Death is the making of
The North Water, Ian McGuire’s bloody, gripping novel set in the middle of the 19th century aboard the Volunteer . . . The language has a harsh, surprising beauty that contrasts the spectacular setting with the greedy, bankrupt men who force their way northward, armed with harpoons for slaughter . . . Powerful’ (New Statesman on The North Water )

About the Author

'The North Water has exceptional power and energy' (Nick Rennison, Sunday Times on The North Water )

'A vivid read, full of twists, turns, period detail and strong characters . . . An enjoyable contrast to most literary fiction' (Robbie Millen, The Times on The North Water )

'Brilliant, fast paced, gripping. A tour de force of narrative tension and a masterful reconstruction of a lost world' (Hilary Mantel on The North Water )

‘Riveting and darkly brilliant . . .
The North Water feels like the result of an encounter between Joseph Conrad and Cormac McCarthy in some run down port as they offer each other a long, sour nod of recognition. McGuire has an extraordinary talent’ (Colm Toibin, New York Times on The North Water )

'A novel that takes us to the limits of flesh and blood. Utterly convincing and compelling, remorselessly vivid and insidiously witty. A startling achievement' (Martin Amis on The North Water )

'A stunning achievement, by turns great fun and shocking, thrilling and provocative. Behold: one of the finest books of the year' (James Kidd, Independent on The North Water )

'McGuire delivers one bravura set piece after another . . .
The North Water has, in places, a Conrad–Melville undercurrent, but for the most part it is Dickens’s influence that is most keenly felt . . . This is a stunning novel, one that snares the reader from the outset and keeps the tightest grip until its bitter end' (Financial Times on The North Water )

'Horrifically gripping. Such fine writing might have been lifted from the pages of Herman Melville’s
Moby Dick’ (Independent on Sunday on The North Water )

'Terrific, seamed with pitch black humour and possessed of a momentum that's kept up to the final, unexpected but resoundingly satisfying scene ... Inspired' (Stephanie Cross, Daily Mail on The North Water )

'As a storyteller, McGuire has a sure and unwavering touch, and he has engineered a superbly compelling suspense narrative . . . As a stylist, too, McGuire is never less than assured . . . a writer of exceptional craft and confidence' (Paraic O'Connell, Irish times on The North Water )

'Raw and compulsively readable . . . think
The Revenant for the Arctic Circle' (The Millions on The North Water )

'This book is quite a ride . . . The powerful story and the riches of the setting do not romanticise the past' (Erica Wagner, New Statesman on The North Water )

‘Death is the making of
The North Water, Ian McGuire’s bloody, gripping novel set in the middle of the 19th century aboard the Volunteer . . . The language has a harsh, surprising beauty that contrasts the spectacular setting with the greedy, bankrupt men who force their way northward, armed with harpoons for slaughter . . . Powerful’ (New Statesman on The North Water )

The North Water is brilliant. A fast paced gripping story set in a world where ‘why’ is not a question and murder happens on a whim; but where a faint ray of grace and hope lights up the landscape of salt and blood and ice’ (Hilary Mantel on The North Water )

‘The strength of
The North Water lies in its well researched detail and persuasive descriptions of the cold, violence, cruelty and the raw, bloody business of whale killing. The Volunteer is rotten from the outset . . . The ship becomes a morally null universe, isolated on the north water. There are echoes here of Conrad’s Heart of Darkness’ (Helen Dunmore, The Guardian on The North Water )

‘McGuire delivers not only arresting depictions of bloody destruction, but moments of fine prose that recall Seamus Heaney's harsh music. For noirish thrills in an unusual setting, McGuire has the goods and the gore’ (Kirkus Reviews on The North Water )

‘A dark, brilliant yarn . . . An amazing journey’ (Publishing News on The North Water )

‘Ian McGuire’s second novel is an unflinching look at what men do, in extreme circumstances, for money, to survive, or for no reason at all. It has quite a lot in common with TV shows like HBO’s
Deadwood and its many descendants (including Peaky Blinders), and . . . it grips like a horror movie. The North Water is self consciously literary, thick with allusions to other books: Moby Dick, obviously; Conrad; Elizabeth Gaskell’s only historical novel, Sylvia’s Lovers; William Golding’s Rites of Passage trilogy; Frankenstein; Dracula; McGuire’s opening sentence is an ironic allusion to John’s gospel but it also recalls the beginning of the novel that The North Water most resembles, Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian’ (London Review of Books on The North Water )

'Blood, blubber and appalling human violence saturate a tale of a doomed 19th century whaling voyage to the Arctic' (The Sunday Times on The North Water )

'Set in the late 19th century, this is the tale of Patrick Sumner, a former army surgeon who joins a whaler bound for the waters of the Arctic Circle. Why would he take on such a dangerous task? He has a secret to hide. Also worth noting is that Ian McGuire's vivid novel is full of the smells of Victorian Hull, which include the "morning piss stink of just emptied night jars", "the usual tavern stench farts and pipe smoke and spilled ale", "the roaring stench of excrement and decay"; the "residual smell of horse dung and butchery"...I could go on' (The Times on The North Water )

'Prompted by Colm Toibin's superb review in
The New York Times, I lost my Kindle virginity to The North Water, Ian McGuire's chilling tale of whaling and depravity' (Madeline Kean, Sunday Independent (Ireland) on The North Water )

'This terse and grisly novel about the last days of the whaling industry is joint favourite to win the Man Booker Prize' (Sunday Telegraph on The North Water)

  ‘Should there be a dark horse on the [Man Booker] list, this is it. Forget slick, cool, funny and topical, this is the kind of book that captures the imagination, this is what fiction is about – the power of story.’ (Irish Times on The North Water)

'McGuire approached the telling of his novel with a linguistic panache seldom seen in contemporary British fiction' (The Irish Times on The North Water )

Product details

  • ASIN ‏ : ‎ B015MQA2W2
  • Publisher ‏ : ‎ Henry Holt and Co. (March 15, 2016)
  • Publication date ‏ : ‎ March 15, 2016
  • Language ‏ : ‎ English
  • File size ‏ : ‎ 1.8 MB
  • Text-to-Speech ‏ : ‎ Enabled
  • Screen Reader ‏ : ‎ Supported
  • Enhanced typesetting ‏ : ‎ Enabled
  • X-Ray ‏ : ‎ Enabled
  • Word Wise ‏ : ‎ Enabled
  • Print length ‏ : ‎ 270 pages
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.3 4.3 out of 5 stars 15,131 ratings

About the author

Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations.
Ian McGuire
Brief content visible, double tap to read full content.
Full content visible, double tap to read brief content.

Discover more of the author’s books, see similar authors, read book recommendations and more.

Customer reviews

4.3 out of 5 stars
15,131 global ratings

Review this product

Share your thoughts with other customers

Customers say

Customers find the book engaging and entertaining. They praise the compelling narrative and well-written plot with moving scenes. The writing quality is described as stunning, rich, and captivating. Readers appreciate the character development and depth, describing the characters as textured, real, and vivid in their minds. They commend the author's deep understanding of the historical period and insightful dialogue. However, opinions differ on the level of violence, with some finding it disturbing and sensual while others consider it graphic and gory.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

522 customers mention "Story quality"431 positive91 negative

Customers enjoy the compelling narrative and well-written tale. They find the plot engaging with moving scenes and shocking twists that keep them enthralled. The author weaves a spell of intricate tension and breathtaking language that keeps readers engrossed throughout. The final lines of the book are haunting and leave readers pondering everything that came before. Overall, customers describe the book as a remarkable story of the sea.

"...Readers who appreciate good storytelling and literature, especially with a historical setting, will be hard pushed to find a finer, recent novel..." Read more

"...While that leaves plenty of room to write a taut, effective narrative, it still seems rather puzzling (and dissatisfying) to have an author take on..." Read more

"...His characterizations are deep and utterly believable, and his dialogue, which uses more foul language than I can recall seeing in many a moon, is..." Read more

"...It's a quick read that moves along nicely but has clunky transitions at times and what felt like a rushed patchwork ending...." Read more

498 customers mention "Readability"494 positive4 negative

Customers find the book engaging and entertaining. They describe it as a riveting adventure story with an unexpected ending. Readers appreciate the multifaceted plot that appeals to historical fiction fans as well as those looking for a thrilling ride.

"...Repugnant and amazing events begin to take place quickly after the Volunteer takes to the sea and event piles upon event in rapid succession that..." Read more

"...The North Water is a well written, literary adventure novel that merits reading. I recommend it to anyone interested in sea literature." Read more

"...And let's not forget the plot. It too is brilliant and multifaceted; a mystery, a survival (sort of) story, a great sea yarn, and a tale of..." Read more

"...Some of the prose jumps out and elevates the story but then it downshifts to better-than-average...." Read more

349 customers mention "Writing quality"319 positive30 negative

Customers praise the writing quality of the book. They find it well-written, with vivid descriptions and witty characters. The language is described as breathtaking and captivating. Readers describe the story as exciting, dark, and violent.

"...entire novel and it is carefully crafted throughout, containing the finest of language choices...." Read more

"...For example, while I think that the author does a good job of tracing the protagonist’s evolution from a defeated, ineffectual sad sack to a tough,..." Read more

"...However, his writing is dazzling; he creates a world of 19th Century whaling that is much more real than that of Melville..." Read more

"Rough language. Lots of scatological stuff but it packs a punch" Read more

173 customers mention "Character development"134 positive39 negative

Customers enjoy the character development. They find the characters textured and vivid, with authentic dialogue and exposition. The plot is engaging and the writer shows rather than tells.

"...The North Water: the settings, the times, the action, the characters and dialogue, and the many plot twists all jump from the page and pull the..." Read more

"...His prose is also solid and he’s a proficient enough writer to show character rather than tell, that is, he lets the characters’ actions bring out..." Read more

"...The villain is very well written as a force of nature/evil but most of the other characters don't rise above TV trope land, including the main..." Read more

"...There are no sympathetic characters but as the tale progresses, I couldn't help finding myself most connected to Sumner, the ship's surgeon...." Read more

76 customers mention "Insight"76 positive0 negative

Customers enjoy the book's insight and historical knowledge. They find the characters believable and the dialogue spellbinding. The descriptions are detailed and explicit, providing an immersive experience. The narration style creates a sense of immediacy and urgency.

"...Let’s deal with the positive aspects first. McGuire has a deep understanding and knowledge of the historical period about which he writes, mid-19th..." Read more

"...His characterizations are deep and utterly believable, and his dialogue, which uses more foul language than I can recall seeing in many a moon, is..." Read more

"...The descriptions of life on board ship are well researched and the characters begin to emerge in a subtle and engaging way...." Read more

"...As the protagonist, the ship surgeon, Sumner, is complex, multi-faceted, and empathic. This is one of the best novels I've ever read...." Read more

334 customers mention "Violence level"154 positive180 negative

Customers have different views on the violence level in the book. Some find it exciting and disturbing, with descriptive gore and maudlin scenarios. Others describe it as graphic, gory, and brutal.

"...The North Water contains credible and vivid scenes of violence, the horrors of trying to survive in a most hostile environment, and for some, a..." Read more

"...Sumner, and its villain, the harpoonist Henry Drax, often seems overly stark...." Read more

"Ian McGuire has fashioned a high suspense drama full of descriptive gore and maudlin scenarios...." Read more

"...it but decided it was not your kind of book, think again; yes, it's bleak, but it's brilliant and deserves your attention." Read more

163 customers mention "Pacing"111 positive52 negative

Customers have differing opinions about the pacing of the book. Some find it fast-paced and engaging, with moments of genuine excitement. Others feel the plot is flawed and the denouement feels rushed. The language and descriptions are often dark, making the book not suitable for lighthearted readers.

"...He effectively involves the reader in the desperate, repeated dangers faced by ordinary seamen aboard a whaling ship and does a vivid job of..." Read more

"...It's a quick read that moves along nicely but has clunky transitions at times and what felt like a rushed patchwork ending...." Read more

"...that I relished each page and found that in some ways the book went too quickly -- but only in the sense that I so loved his writing that I wish it..." Read more

"...It was a very fast read. McGuire knows how to keep the reader hooked and despite the gruesome and sensory sickening events, it is near brilliant...." Read more

42 customers mention "Dark tone"27 positive15 negative

Customers have mixed opinions about the tone of the book. Some find it captivating and violent, while others say it's quite dark and not exactly what they expected.

"...icy cold wave of sea water and deposits one right in the sick, stinky, dark, dangerous, and fascinating world of the 19th century Whaling industry...." Read more

"...The novel is dark but not graphic. Ian McGuire does a great job describing the characters and the world...." Read more

"...He has written an exciting, dark, violent novel that will appeal to readers who like historical fiction as well as those looking for a bit of..." Read more

"...But a gorgeously dark, gorgeously violent novel." Read more

A good story, but rather cursory
4 out of 5 stars
A good story, but rather cursory
I looked forward to reading this novel quite a bit due to its subject and the warm critical reviews it received. Although I’m the world’s cruddiest sailor (stir up the water in a bathtub and I’ll get seasick), sagas of grueling sea voyages during the age of sail have always fascinated me. The Hornblower series delighted me as a child and I also got a big kick out of Nordhoff and Hall’s Mutiny On The Bounty. I also read Moby Dick when I was about fifteen and even went through the long, nonfiction section of the novel where Melville described the 19th-Century whaling industry in fascinating detail (to me anyway). More recently, I enjoyed reading Nigel Cliff’s account of Vasco Da Gama’s historic circumnavigation of the African continent.So with all that nautical lit background, I read McGuire’s North Water with much anticipation. While I think that the work is a solid piece of literature, I do have a few criticisms. Let’s deal with the positive aspects first. McGuire has a deep understanding and knowledge of the historical period about which he writes, mid-19th Century Great Britain. At the same time, he never falls prey to one of the worst temptations a historical novelist must deal with, the proclivity to include entirely too much information about a particular era to the detriment of the novel’s plot. His prose is also solid and he’s a proficient enough writer to show character rather than tell, that is, he lets the characters’ actions bring out their true natures. McGuire also has a gift for generating suspense. He effectively involves the reader in the desperate, repeated dangers faced by ordinary seamen aboard a whaling ship and does a vivid job of portraying the terrifying, body and soul destroying rigors involved in survival in an Arctic environment. McGuire is also plainly aware of the literary traditions that he works within, paying indirect tribute to the previously cited Moby Dick.At the same time, I must say I thought the author’s treatment of his subject was rather cursory. The novel is pretty short, not much more than two hundred and fifty pages. While that leaves plenty of room to write a taut, effective narrative, it still seems rather puzzling (and dissatisfying) to have an author take on traditional, old fashioned themes (men at sea, the clash between good and evil, the essential nature of human character) and not deal with it at the magisterial, comprehensive, Olympian level of literature employed by such 19th Century masters as Hugo and Dickens. For example, while I think that the author does a good job of tracing the protagonist’s evolution from a defeated, ineffectual sad sack to a tough, determined man of the world, it seems to me that this could have been done more believably and interestingly if McGuire had allowed himself more scope.A last point of criticism: the dichotomy between the novel’s hero, Patrick Sumner, and its villain, the harpoonist Henry Drax, often seems overly stark. While Sumner is portrayed as weak, fallible, and full of doubt, Drax is shown as always certain, in fact apparently superhuman, much like the line from the Yeats poem: “And the best lack all conviction while the worst are filled with a passionate intensity.” The author does seem to intimate at several times during the course of the novel that Drax is somehow close to immortal, not subject to the regular rules of reality that usually trip up and destroy human beings. Without trying to give anything away to anyone who hasn’t read the novel, the sudden reversal of this tension at the end of the novel was rather jarring to me and detracted from the book’s persuasiveness as a work of fiction.Despite these criticisms, I still think that The North Water is a well written, literary adventure novel that merits reading. I recommend it to anyone interested in sea literature.
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry, there was an error
Sorry we couldn't load the review

Top reviews from the United States

  • Reviewed in the United States on April 14, 2017
    The year is 1859 and the whaling industry, once a thriving and profitable business is dying. “We killed them all,” complains a whaling ship owner referring to the whales—in thirty years of excessive hunting and killing. Petroleum and coal is the future, he declares. None the less, his ship, the Volunteer, is about to set sail on a six-month voyage, headed toward northern waters—the area where whales are still most likely to be found, although far from abundant. Such is the time period of Ian McGiuire’s fascinating and very dark novel, The North Water (2016), long listed for the Man Booker Prize.

    McGuire paints a vivid and bleak picture aboard the Volunteer. Just as an arboretum and botanical garden produce things of beauty, the area of London in which some of the whalers that board the Volunteer lurk before shipping out and the Volunteer itself rapidly becomes a petri dish that facilitates the growth of sordidness, evil, murder, and worse—all magnified by the true and villainous purpose of the voyage of the ship kept secret from most of the crew—all of whom fall victim to a scheme they know nothing about as well as the perfidy of some of those aboard ship.

    McGuire takes a realistic approach to his entire novel and it is carefully crafted throughout, containing the finest of language choices. Everything about The North Water: the settings, the times, the action, the characters and dialogue, and the many plot twists all jump from the page and pull the reader into the world of a whaling ship. The North Water, however, is no mere sea adventure.

    With the decline in profits for those working in the whaling industry comes a decline in character for those still willing to risk their lives on the open seas. McGuire wastes no time in painting a stark portrait of many of his characters in Dark Water—men, for the most part, who are not heroic figures of courage and stamina, but scoundrels with notorious pasts and equally abhorrent presents who make little effort to hide their true nature. It is McGuire’s character development: who they are, what they are, and what they do that is the most gripping aspect of the novel. One expects men engaged in such laborious work that takes them far from home for long stretches to be out of the ordinary, hardened, and insensitive to many aspects of life. “If you are seeking persons of gentleness and refinement, Sumner, the Greenland whaling trade is not the place to look for them,” cautions the captain of the Volunteer. The majority of the men aboard the Volunteer, however, are even worse.

    Soiled reputations and secrets abound among the crew. Captain Brownlee, with thirty years of command under his belt, is “notable for his fearsome ill luck,” having been the commander of the Percival, a whaling ship that went down with loss of life, multiple injuries, and loss of cargo. The ship’s surgeon, Patrick Sumner, is on the run from his past after having served in India and having partaken in a most unethical and unfortunate incident. His refuge is not only to board the Volunteer accepting a position far below his skill level, but from the laudanum bottle. First Mate Cavendish is a “whoremonger” who lords his authority over the crew. The head harpooner, Henry Dax, carries with him even darker secrets. Each of these men play pivotal roles in the novel and as the ship heads further north into more and more dangerous waters filled with glistening ice, chunks of which become of greater size and magnitude, nature itself becomes an awesome, uncontrollable player as well.

    Repugnant and amazing events begin to take place quickly after the Volunteer takes to the sea and event piles upon event in rapid succession that will hold the reader spellbound. McGuire’s storytelling is above reproach. By mid-novel, the crew “fear worse is yet to come, and they would rather reach home with empty pockets but still breathing than end up sunk forever below the Baffin ice.” Turning back is not an option, nor part of the plan, however.

    Any novel dealing with whaling in the 1800s is bound to have allusions to Herman Melville’s immortal classic, Moby Dick (1851) and The North Water is no exception. The descriptions of men in small boats pursuing and killing giant behemoths in the open sea are white-knuckle reading material. Melville’s respect for both the animals and the men that hunt them are obvious as they are in McGuire’s work in spite of the insidious nature of some of his characters. Melville’s inclusion of the mystical and dreams also make its way into The North Water. The most obvious comparison between The North Water and Moby Dick will not go unnoticed by readers familiar with the American landmark novel.

    The North Water contains credible and vivid scenes of violence, the horrors of trying to survive in a most hostile environment, and for some, a handful of stomach-turning moments when it comes to bodily functions and physical injuries and within keeping faith to the novel’s tone and authenticity.

    In some ways the conclusion of The North Water is inevitable, but McGuire’s use of suspense and exceptional plotting of his story leaves readers with no certainty as to exactly what will happen until the final page is reached. Readers who appreciate good storytelling and literature, especially with a historical setting, will be hard pushed to find a finer, recent novel than The North Water to satisfy their reading needs.
    58 people found this helpful
    Report
  • Reviewed in the United States on March 6, 2017
    I looked forward to reading this novel quite a bit due to its subject and the warm critical reviews it received. Although I’m the world’s cruddiest sailor (stir up the water in a bathtub and I’ll get seasick), sagas of grueling sea voyages during the age of sail have always fascinated me. The Hornblower series delighted me as a child and I also got a big kick out of Nordhoff and Hall’s Mutiny On The Bounty. I also read Moby Dick when I was about fifteen and even went through the long, nonfiction section of the novel where Melville described the 19th-Century whaling industry in fascinating detail (to me anyway). More recently, I enjoyed reading Nigel Cliff’s account of Vasco Da Gama’s historic circumnavigation of the African continent.

    So with all that nautical lit background, I read McGuire’s North Water with much anticipation. While I think that the work is a solid piece of literature, I do have a few criticisms. Let’s deal with the positive aspects first. McGuire has a deep understanding and knowledge of the historical period about which he writes, mid-19th Century Great Britain. At the same time, he never falls prey to one of the worst temptations a historical novelist must deal with, the proclivity to include entirely too much information about a particular era to the detriment of the novel’s plot. His prose is also solid and he’s a proficient enough writer to show character rather than tell, that is, he lets the characters’ actions bring out their true natures. McGuire also has a gift for generating suspense. He effectively involves the reader in the desperate, repeated dangers faced by ordinary seamen aboard a whaling ship and does a vivid job of portraying the terrifying, body and soul destroying rigors involved in survival in an Arctic environment. McGuire is also plainly aware of the literary traditions that he works within, paying indirect tribute to the previously cited Moby Dick.

    At the same time, I must say I thought the author’s treatment of his subject was rather cursory. The novel is pretty short, not much more than two hundred and fifty pages. While that leaves plenty of room to write a taut, effective narrative, it still seems rather puzzling (and dissatisfying) to have an author take on traditional, old fashioned themes (men at sea, the clash between good and evil, the essential nature of human character) and not deal with it at the magisterial, comprehensive, Olympian level of literature employed by such 19th Century masters as Hugo and Dickens. For example, while I think that the author does a good job of tracing the protagonist’s evolution from a defeated, ineffectual sad sack to a tough, determined man of the world, it seems to me that this could have been done more believably and interestingly if McGuire had allowed himself more scope.

    A last point of criticism: the dichotomy between the novel’s hero, Patrick Sumner, and its villain, the harpoonist Henry Drax, often seems overly stark. While Sumner is portrayed as weak, fallible, and full of doubt, Drax is shown as always certain, in fact apparently superhuman, much like the line from the Yeats poem: “And the best lack all conviction while the worst are filled with a passionate intensity.” The author does seem to intimate at several times during the course of the novel that Drax is somehow close to immortal, not subject to the regular rules of reality that usually trip up and destroy human beings. Without trying to give anything away to anyone who hasn’t read the novel, the sudden reversal of this tension at the end of the novel was rather jarring to me and detracted from the book’s persuasiveness as a work of fiction.

    Despite these criticisms, I still think that The North Water is a well written, literary adventure novel that merits reading. I recommend it to anyone interested in sea literature.
    Customer image
    4.0 out of 5 stars
    A good story, but rather cursory

    Reviewed in the United States on March 6, 2017
    I looked forward to reading this novel quite a bit due to its subject and the warm critical reviews it received. Although I’m the world’s cruddiest sailor (stir up the water in a bathtub and I’ll get seasick), sagas of grueling sea voyages during the age of sail have always fascinated me. The Hornblower series delighted me as a child and I also got a big kick out of Nordhoff and Hall’s Mutiny On The Bounty. I also read Moby Dick when I was about fifteen and even went through the long, nonfiction section of the novel where Melville described the 19th-Century whaling industry in fascinating detail (to me anyway). More recently, I enjoyed reading Nigel Cliff’s account of Vasco Da Gama’s historic circumnavigation of the African continent.

    So with all that nautical lit background, I read McGuire’s North Water with much anticipation. While I think that the work is a solid piece of literature, I do have a few criticisms. Let’s deal with the positive aspects first. McGuire has a deep understanding and knowledge of the historical period about which he writes, mid-19th Century Great Britain. At the same time, he never falls prey to one of the worst temptations a historical novelist must deal with, the proclivity to include entirely too much information about a particular era to the detriment of the novel’s plot. His prose is also solid and he’s a proficient enough writer to show character rather than tell, that is, he lets the characters’ actions bring out their true natures. McGuire also has a gift for generating suspense. He effectively involves the reader in the desperate, repeated dangers faced by ordinary seamen aboard a whaling ship and does a vivid job of portraying the terrifying, body and soul destroying rigors involved in survival in an Arctic environment. McGuire is also plainly aware of the literary traditions that he works within, paying indirect tribute to the previously cited Moby Dick.

    At the same time, I must say I thought the author’s treatment of his subject was rather cursory. The novel is pretty short, not much more than two hundred and fifty pages. While that leaves plenty of room to write a taut, effective narrative, it still seems rather puzzling (and dissatisfying) to have an author take on traditional, old fashioned themes (men at sea, the clash between good and evil, the essential nature of human character) and not deal with it at the magisterial, comprehensive, Olympian level of literature employed by such 19th Century masters as Hugo and Dickens. For example, while I think that the author does a good job of tracing the protagonist’s evolution from a defeated, ineffectual sad sack to a tough, determined man of the world, it seems to me that this could have been done more believably and interestingly if McGuire had allowed himself more scope.

    A last point of criticism: the dichotomy between the novel’s hero, Patrick Sumner, and its villain, the harpoonist Henry Drax, often seems overly stark. While Sumner is portrayed as weak, fallible, and full of doubt, Drax is shown as always certain, in fact apparently superhuman, much like the line from the Yeats poem: “And the best lack all conviction while the worst are filled with a passionate intensity.” The author does seem to intimate at several times during the course of the novel that Drax is somehow close to immortal, not subject to the regular rules of reality that usually trip up and destroy human beings. Without trying to give anything away to anyone who hasn’t read the novel, the sudden reversal of this tension at the end of the novel was rather jarring to me and detracted from the book’s persuasiveness as a work of fiction.

    Despite these criticisms, I still think that The North Water is a well written, literary adventure novel that merits reading. I recommend it to anyone interested in sea literature.
    Images in this review
    Customer image
    16 people found this helpful
    Report

Top reviews from other countries

Translate all reviews to English
  • Jerry G.
    5.0 out of 5 stars A GOOD READ
    Reviewed in Canada on June 9, 2023
    A pretty dark story...atmospheric. Well written right to the end. Sometimes it feels like endings are difficult to write. THE NORTH WATER keeps the writing quality and interest very high right through the last word.
  • Abhishek Dasgupta
    5.0 out of 5 stars Wonderful and easy read
    Reviewed in India on July 15, 2023
    The novel has all materials in it! It has thriller, detective, adventure, love - all the genres punched together. I found this book while I was yearning for a maritime adventure and it's certainly a deserving one.
  • DM
    5.0 out of 5 stars Proof positive of what's wrong with the Booker Prize...
    Reviewed in the United Kingdom on January 3, 2021
    Gripping, entertaining and brilliantly written...I highly and enthusiastically recommend 'The North Water'.
    This is an original and unusual piece of writing; combining the ideal blend of quality literature while twinned with both an unusual and riveting tale. Only seldom do these two ideals marry together but as and when they do....
    We have something in the way of alchemy for the intelligent, imaginative reader.
    'Long listed' for the Booker Prize I note. This sums the Booker up perfectly to my mind-having read a number of Booker winners and thought, 'Really? Really??' And yet this very clever and entertaining book was only, 'Long Listed'. So thank you Booker. You have confirmed what I have always previously suspected.
    P.S. Do you know what kept Ultravox 'Vienna' off the Number 1 spot? Yup. That's right... Joe Dolce 'Shaddap You Face'.
    The Pulitzer Prize for fiction? Yes. The Booker? Err... No.
  • Robert Hierl
    5.0 out of 5 stars Großartige Seemannsgeschichte.
    Reviewed in Germany on December 11, 2020
    Ein spannender, toll geschriebener Roman über einen Schiffsarzt, der sich nach persönlichen Rückschlägen in die Seefahrt zurückzieht und dort auf einen Psychopathen stößt. Es entspinnt sich ein nervenzerreissendes Katz- und Mausspiel, das seinen Höhepunkt in einem Kampf um Leben und Tod findet.
    Ein sehr realistisches, hartes und oft grausames Buch, das die Härten der Seefahrt im 19. Jahrhundert großartig darstellt.
  • de cara henry
    5.0 out of 5 stars bien !!!!!
    Reviewed in France on February 15, 2018
    J'ai beaucoup aimé ce livre ,fort et au vocabulaire fourni et varié.
    Un peu rude, un peu dur mais cela nous fait apprecier le confort de notre siecle !

Report an issue


Does this item contain inappropriate content?
Do you believe that this item violates a copyright?
Does this item contain quality or formatting issues?